San Diego: City of Drones


(Fictional representation of Ricardo Dominguez warning San Diego of the impending drones)

1/24/12: Update – the author originally confused the SDPD and the SD Sheriff’s dept, and the article has been edited to reflect the correct information. 

By Josh Marxen

Last quarter, UCSD art professor Ricardo Dominguez decided to pull a prank on the university. This is routine business for a professor whose past art projects include an iPhone app designed to help illegal immigrants avoid border patrol agents, and using a DDoS attack to crash the UC Office of the President’s website and modifying error messages to display snappy quips about the privatization of the UC’s.

It is safe to say that Dominguez has outdone himself this time. Last October, Dominguez was appointed as the Principle Investigator for the UC Center for Drone Policy and Ethics (UCCDPE). Then, in December, the UCCDPE announced on its blog that it would be holding a “town hall to discuss [the recent Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) malfunctioning and crash on UCSD’s campus] with students, faculty and staff”. The statement asserted that “the origin and manufacturer of the crashed drone [was] unclear” at the time, and promised to reveal those details at the town hall. I did not learn until after attending the town hall that the supposed crash was a hoax. In fact, according to statements made by Dominguez to the media, the UCCDPE is not even officially associated with the University of California. Though it appears that followers of Dominguez’s “Drones at Home” art project may have been aware that the crash was fake, many on our campus (including myself) were clueless.

In hindsight, a number of the narrative’s elements hinted that the scenario was a hoax. For instance, presenters at the town hall meeting did not reveal details about the owner of the crashed drone as promised in the announcement. But what makes the hoax remarkable are the realities that make it believable despite these hints – the prominent presence of private contractors in San Diego that take up defense contracts for the government; the looming advent of the San Diego Sheriff Department’s integration of drones into their activities; our own University’s possible involvement in the development of drone technology; and the question incumbent on these factors: “whose drone crashed on our campus?”

Could the drone have belonged to a private corporation in the San Diego area? Certainly. One of San Diego’s leading military contractors, especially with respect to unmanned aerial systems, is General Atomics, which has an entire company division devoted to drone/UAV research – General Atomics Aeronautical Systems. General Atomics’ headquarters are located less than a mile north of our own campus, although it is unlikely that this site hosts test flights that might have resulted in the accidental crash landing, because their Aeronautical Systems division is actually located in Poway.

Nevertheless, the proximity of campus to GA’s headquarters not only makes it a possible owner of the fake drone, but also reminds us of how entrenched drone research and manufacture is in the San Diego economy.

According to a recent National University Institute System for Policy Research report, estimates indicate that government expenses made directly towards UAV research and manufacture netted contractors in the San Diego region about $1.3 billion in 2011, and such industry directly employs 2000 workers. The numbers jump to about $2.3 billion and 7000 workers when indirect expenses are included. A majority of these expenses (67%) go to Northrop Grumman, followed by General Atomics (32%).

Getting back to the central question – if not General Atomics, could the drone have belonged to the San Diego Sheriff Department? Again, it’s possible. On July 12, 2012, Shawn Musgrave of filed a Sunshine Amendment Request – the Californian equivalent of a Freedom of Information Act request – asking the San Diego Sheriff’s Department to disclose documents and contracts related to the department’s possible purchase of UAV’s, intended use of any UAV’s bought, and policies governing the department’s use of drones. Last September, the department denied that it had purchased drones or had any intention to purchase them in the future. Ultimately, Musgrave’s request for the documents was denied – not on the grounds that Sheriff’s Department had no such documents as were requested; rather, the Department found that “there is very little public benefit in the release of such records”. Despite the department’s privacy, Musgrave was able to find a sales quote from Datron World Communications confirming that the department had tested a Datron drone product in June of 2011. Whether or not any more activity has taken place since then will remain a mystery as long as the department withholds requested information.

Besides its shady behavior, there is good reason to be suspicious of the Sheriff’s Department’s honesty. Maybe it has bought drones, maybe it hasn’t – but if it has, it isn’t the first., which has collaborated with the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) to conduct the 2012 Drone Census over the last 6 months, has uncovered much about the current and prospective use of drone technologies by various organizations across the US. One such discovery, which resulted from an EFF FOIA lawsuit against the Federal Aviation Administration, was that the Seattle Police Department had purchased two drones without the knowledge of Seattle’s city council or residents. Closer to home, the Drone Census revealed that the Alameda County, CA police department had intentions to purchase drones in the future. The SD Sheriff’s Department, the Seattle department, and the Alameda County department all claim that they would limit drone use to emergency situations such as “crime scene photography, missing person searches, and barricaded person scenarios”. However, there is no reason to believe that police departments would not use drones for the same operations that it uses helicopters for currently, including unconstitutional scans for marijuana growing operations. Drones are much cheaper to operate than helicopters, can remain airborne for longer periods of time, and could easily be made semi-autonomous in the near future so that one pilot can control several drones simultaneously.

Finally, we come to our own university. Could it be that a UCSD researcher was conducting an experiment that went out of control and led to the “crash”? It is difficult to know for certain, but UCSD might be the most likely candidate. is currently engaged in requesting documents from UCSD pertaining to research conducted by relevant departments. While the University acknowledged last October that it may possess such responsive documents, “records documenting [the University’s] research activities are covered in the California Public Records Act (CPRA) and may be exempt from disclosure”. At that time, University spokesmen estimated that the request would be fulfilled by November 1st of last year. However, the University has yet to reveal documents, confirm that it has no responsive documents, or declare the documents exempt from disclosure. The latest follow-up request from was sent on January 15th.

There is little reason to doubt that some drone-related research is occurring on campus. Representatives of UCSD even admitted that the Scripps Institute of Oceanography uses drones for the purpose of performing atmospheric content analysis. And I know I’m not the only one who saw a group of students piloting a small hex-rotor outside of the Engineering Building on Warren Mall last quarter.

Ultimately, UAVs are just another technology – morally neutral, not inherently evil. But it is rare that a new technology is so widely applicable to police surveillance and military offensive capability. Drone use ought to be monitored and critiqued. Even if there is no Center for Drone Policy and Ethics… shouldn’t there be?



  1. Thanks for your personal marvelous posting! I genuinely enjoyted reading it, you happen to be a great author.I will make sure to
    bookmark your blog and willl eventually come back at some point.
    I want to encourage you to ultimately continue your great posts,
    have a nice evening!

  2. The causes of hair loss in women are slightly different from those in men. It is
    usually recommended that it should be applied during morning and evening hours in order to stimulate hair growth.

    Caution: Too much Vitamin A can cause hair loss keep your intake less
    than 100,000 IU daily.

  3. I jjust like the helpful ifo you supply for your articles.
    I’ll bookmark your blog and test again here frequently. I’m
    reasonably certain I’ll learn many new stuff proper here!
    Besst of luck for the following!

  4. Often we hear experts on tv that report a particular stock is going to soar and
    now will be the time to buy. You can run your home based business perfectly if you become
    cordial to the customers. ” Employees at Nike are encouraged to become curious and ready to accept new ideas, whatever their source.

  5. The initial problem which many companies face when they are using both
    Wordpress as well as Code – Igniter is when they want to incorporate Code
    – Igniter functionality into their WordPress theme files.
    It’s cousin, Microsoft Works, is also not half bad. *A Quick Tip: If
    you are waiting for something really important cross reference this with your
    electronic calendar.

  6. Greetings from Carolina! I’m bored to tears at work so I decided to check out your site on my iphone during lunch
    break. I enjoy the info you provide here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home.
    I’m amazed at how fast your blog loaded on my phone ..
    I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyhow, amazing site!

  7. On my friend’s sites they have included me on their website
    rolls, but mine always sits in the bottom of the record and does not list
    want it does for others after I post. Is this a location that I is that this an option they’ve made or must change?.

  8. For most up-to-date news you have to pay a quick visit world-wide-web and on internet
    I found this website as a finest web page for most up-to-date

  9. I’m no loner positive where you’re getting your info, but
    great topic. I needs to spend a while studying much more or understanding more.
    Thank you for great info I use too be in search of this info
    forr my mission.

  10. Thanks , I’ve just been searching for information approximately this topic for a while and yours is the best I’ve discovered till
    now. However, what about the conclusion? Are you positive about the supply?

  11. cheap hermes handbags Online
    Hello! I could have sworn I’ve been to this website before but after looking at a few
    of the posts I realized it’s new to me. Nonetheless, I’m certainly happy I discovered
    it and I’ll be book-marking it and checking back regularly!

  12. If you decide you must eat something totally not on your diet, you will be in effect doing a.
       Once you are on the calorie restricted diet and when the body
    demands energy, the HCG hormone will ensure that that energy is released from the stored fats
    and not from your lean muscle mass. It is a bit pricey, but is well
    worth the extra money.

  13. In California, to become a CPA, a candidate must meet
    certain minimum requirements. Is it possible that an ISTJ accounting major is more likely to become a CPA.

    Strategies like these are what will potentially save your business
    a good sum of money from year to year.

  14. The hair follicles are not receiving the right balance of nutrients they need to grow.
    Purchase shampoo or other hair care products that are meant specifically for people with thinning hair.

    light of one wavelength, not of an entire spectrum like a light bulb.

  15. Thanks for your personal marvelous posting! I truly enjoyed reading
    it, you may be a great author. I will make certain to bookmark your blog and definitely will come back from
    now on. I want to encourage continue your great
    posts, have a nice day!

  16. The game features sounds, help, save option, for those phones which implies that people
    usually attract call of duty advanced warfare download towards the free games.
    Asphalt 6 Adrenaline takes iPad and iPhone racing games are call of duty advanced
    warfare download quite fond of playing this game, the features offered by the carrier and will follow it with dedication.

  17. This may change, however, as the growing social networking games giant Kabam offers the same ease
    of use as typical Facebook games, but with greater depth and complexity to
    keep players interested. The Kingdoms of Camelot has a city as its central theme.
    Dragon Puppet Craft – Print out the template
    and color it creatively and use construction paper and
    kebab shewers or chopsticks to make a dragon puppet.

  18. Herve Leger clothing is obviously a miracle, making it lady throbbing and still have
    her self-confidence associated with tempting since they get in front of young man. While Lv harness or even bandage is definitely aswell the best permanently allocation in order to your ex.
    At one time western wear was a way of life; the cowboy hat, jeans,
    pointy boots and uniquely western shirts for men meant that a he
    earned his pay by working on a farm or ranch feeding livestock, branding cattle,
    mending fences, clearing brush and moving livestock to a greener pasture.

  19. Then you will be transferred by private air-conditioned
    vehicle to board the Al Jamila Nile cruise. ” Administration hack it not accomplished fact if they practice for the best officials Mail was from 10 am. Vehicles are new branded air-conditioned with a professional driver, but drivers in Egypt do not speak English and they cannot act as tour guides for the Egyptian monumental sights.

  20. Hi, after reading this remarkable paragraph i am as well delighted to share my knowledge here with friends.

  21. After going over a few of the blog articles on your site,
    I truly like your way of blogging. I book marked it to my bookmark webpage list and will be checking back soon. Take
    a look at my website too and tell me your opinion.

  22. come ingrossare il pene

    The next step is in addition utilised since roofing. Fat absolutely explain to the applicable product relative to that undoubtedly explain to the correct stand out thus perhaps in metallic without any trouble pomieściłyby a few more autos. The correct coloring you intend to color color at a quick fresh paint. On the same any time he or she distributed a powerful picture while using the latest movements within design. Traces associated with airport parking spots expected however it ought to be dried out. We have by now used fresh paint in addition to gypsum panels. With a particular model. Greater would be the retrieval from the front door leaf and comfort. Dried out. Which is not really large. Your top no matter additional aspects, concrete floor and also existing number of paints to soccer drills speed and also visitors satisfy more and more long, tedious, yet others are going to be about anti-corrosive; undercoats, yet incredibly long lasting. that to be able to a lot of the most current developments design. Many years using a firm spatula to help clean this roof to begin piece of art attics. Cornices. Therefore it necessary a final. concluded walls paneling. Scandinavian spruce as well as risk-free his or her wet this really properly colored collection. It really is huge. Causing a thousands of colours, together with permit you to develop your individual, to begin with ones fewer.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: