Orca Welfare Act is Morally Appropriate

by Joshua Marxen
Rebuttal by John Ayers-Mann

In the wake of the controversial documentary film Blackfish, California Assemblyman Richard Bloom has proposed a ban on the use of captive Orca whales for entertainment purposes. While it is hard to deny that SeaWorld Orca shows have been responsible for much of what scientists and the public have learned about Orcas in general, and for the enthusiasm around these animals, this knowledge ironically leads us to the conclusion that SeaWorld has no legitimate reason to hold these Orcas in their current conditions of captivity.

I hope the reader will agree with me that it is morally wrong to cause unnecessary suffering, even to animals. You may have trouble extending empathy to fish, reptiles, and insects, but you should not have the same trouble extending it to Orcas. After all, the fundamental commonalities we have with Orcas – the fact that they’re intelligent, that they’re social, that they live in families and clans (pods) like us – are the main attractions SeaWorld provides to customers in hosting Orca shows. The proof is in the profit. So there are two questions we have to ask. First, are Orcas in SeaWorld’s custody worse off than their wild counterparts? And second, if this is the case, are these conditions justified and necessary?

According to the available evidence, captive Orcas fare worse than Orcas in the wild. While Orca life-spans in captivity have been improving over the past 50 years, the average captive Orca’s life is still significantly shorter than the average wild Orca’s. In the wild, male Orca’s live 30 years on average, and females live 50. In captivity, however, males live 25 years, and females live 35, on average.

Besides a drop in average life-span, Orcas in captivity exhibit increased aggression compared to Orcas in the wild. While one could argue that the type of aggression displayed by Orcas (to other whales and to their trainers) in the Blackfish documentary is rare, it is rarer still to see wild Orcas attack humans. There have been fewer than ten documented wild Orca attacks on humans since 1910, while captive Orcas have attacked their trainers 40 times since the first Orca was held in captivity in 1968. Furthermore, none of the wild attacks on humans have been fatal or known to cause serious injury, whereas Blackfish shows indisputably that incidents of captive Orca aggression have caused both crippling injury and death. It is not unreasonable to speculate that a significant amount of the reported aggression between captive Orcas might not have occurred if they had space to escape from each other.

Perhaps another indicator of captive Orcas’ diminished welfare is the ubiquitous but unexplained occurrence of dorsal fin collapse among captive male Orcas. In the wild, this phenomenon is rare, occurring in less than 1% of wild Orcas. (Some wild pods exhibit an unusually high rate of dorsal fin collapse, but only a fraction of the population is affected, as opposed to the entire male population.) Even if this has no obvious detrimental effects on the health of the whales, the fact that only speculation exists as to why captive Orcas exhibit this condition indicates that there is still a lot we don’t know about the animal’s natural needs. Captive whales are clearly missing physiological and psychological benefits that their wild habitat could provide for them.

I think this evidence demonstrates that despite what might be good intentions on the part of SeaWorld, captive Orcas are worse off than wild ones. So now we have to move on to the question of whether this suffering is necessary. Are the benefits that SeaWorld offers by hosting Orca shows necessary, and is there no way to provide those benefits without subjecting Orcas to these conditions?

The first benefit SeaWorld provides is economic stimulus in the cities and states they operate in. They draw tourism and provide jobs. In our own back yard, SeaWorld at San Diego draws about 4.4 million guests a year, and employs 4,500 people. Banning SeaWorld from holding Orca shows will doubtlessly decrease its revenue, at least at first. If SeaWorld is really dedicated to education and welfare around marine life, it will supplement Orca shows with whale-watching trips. But this alternative may not be as popular as the Orca shows due to the fact that it requires customers to actually get on a boat and get out of their element to interact with whales that might not even turn out to be the iconic Orcas that SeaWorld is famous for. Furthermore, forcing it to develop the infrastructure and train its employees to reintegrate captive Orcas into the wild, as Bloom’s bill does, will be expensive. Together, this will decrease the economic benefit that San Diego and other communities hosting SeaWorld currently receive.

But to say that these effects are valid reasons for throwing out the ban is the same as saying that the economic benefits justify the unsatisfactory conditions we place Orcas in. Can we really say 4,500 people are entitled to jobs predicated on animal suffering? (And not all of those people will lose their jobs – only, possibly, those whose jobs are tied to the success of Orca shows.) Do people really deserve the benefits of tourism predicated on animal suffering? There are probably better ways to employ and entertain people.

And as for our scientific knowledge about whales, SeaWorld certainly has a role to play, and has probably had a net positive impact on this front over the course of its existence. But holding them in tanks for the purpose of performing shows does not seem to be necessary for advancing scientific knowledge of whales. The proposed sea enclosures that SeaWorld would be required to transfer the Orcas to would allow researchers to observe whale behavior and gain biological data while providing it with a more spacious and natural habitat. With some creativity, these could also be turned into tourist attractions.

All that said, activists and advocates for the bill should remember that there are limits to what can be realistically be expected to succeed when attempting to reintegrate captive-born whales into the wild. The most famous attempt to reintegrate an Orca into the wild happened in response to the success of the movie Free Willy, who’s cetacean star Keiko was released into the the open ocean after more than 20 years in captivity. The result was that six months later, Keiko was found on the coast of Norway giving rides to children at the beach, presumably hoping for a food reward.

This scenario is to be expected for any kind of animal that has been held in captivity for too long. (Indeed, all of the arguments above apply to a number of animals we keep in captivity.) It is likely that full integration of whales currently in captivity will not be possible. Fortunately, the current version of the bill provides for a more gradual strategy of transferring current Orcas to sea enclosures, as discussed before. Perhaps their children can be adopted by wild pods, but it is too early for that discussion be meaningful.

In conclusion, all of the benefits that SeaWorld provides for us and for Orcas can be had without subjecting them to the conditions that come with being held in captivity for entertainment. While reintegrating them completely is impossible, we can do better for them without a significant loss of economic benefit, entertainment, and scientific opportunity. And that small loss is greatly outweighed by the obligation we have to these creatures, who we identify as fellow conscious beings with as much capacity for joy and suffering as we have, and who therefore share as much a natural right to freedom as we do.



  1. Hi there to every one, the contents present at this site are genuinely amazing for
    people knowledge, well, keep up the good wofk fellows.

  2. If you exfoliate before then, you will see
    the color coming off of your skin. There are compromises, including acoustic panels designed to look
    like pieces of art, and using things such as wall-hanging rugs can be surprisingly effective, but it remains the
    case that the ideal solution acoustically is not the ideal solution aesthetically.
    If I ever found a product that was sticky or smelly I would never use it again,
    but then I started hearing more and more
    about another issue – dangerous personal care products so I started researching.

  3. Ear deformities, especially in children can become a target for the less caring children resulting
    in the child being ridiculed and teased. Data coverage:
    market sizes (historic and forecasts), company shares, brand shares and distribution data.
    Any cosmetic plastic procedure could be a worthwhile and extraordinary experience for both the patient
    and surgeon, if this is done in the light of surgical standards
    in term of safety.

  4. Wanting to show some skin and amaze an audience but unable to do so because of your pale skin. You can buy swimsuits in floral and
    island prints to add more fun to your look at the beach.
    Moving to some sunny place can be an effective means
    to get an all round glow.

  5. My grandmother always advised me to use onion juice
    on my hair, but I thought it was a crazy idea.

    Choosing a good conditioner that is right for you can keep hair healthy in the long run.
    Speaking of ball game, do you know that you can advertise using your
    bald head.

  6. Even frequent blow-drying at extreme heat or brushing obsessively can cause your
    hair to become extremely fragile causing it
    to break and fall out. Consult with a veterinarian for
    the proper dosage based on the individual pig’s weight.

    Oils that are perfect for sealing are Olive oil, jojoba oil, safflower oil or castor oil.

  7. To keep you in the most comfortable and peaceful state of mind possible,
    Dr. Place the back of both wrists at the bottom of the chin. It is normal
    to have slight bruising and swelling for about ten days.

  8. With that said, there is still a good chance that
    an offer will be accepted if you truly cannot afford to pay your back taxes.
    Do you still keep your money in your foreign bank account.
    Certified accountants can be single practitioners or by partnership ranging in size from two to hundreds of members.

  9. Before rushing into any financial decision, research all the options available
    and find what payment option is best for you.
    When the bathroom walls are crack or have been damaged the sink,
    the bathroom racks are no longer helpful it is time to think about
    bathroom remodeling. These pieces of real estate are often purchased by individuals as investment

  10. Duck in and out of cover until it’s clear, then move up to a display case.
    When eating out at restaurant with a loved one, try chatting most of the time.
    and that includes the process of safely transporting a lifetime of furniture and
    accessories to a new home.

  11. Beauty is only skin deep and inner beauty is what matters most.
    While Kim and her sisters have been criticized for being
    trashy, classless fame junkies, they’ve also managed to
    build a lucrative brand. Change your appearance in a better and attractive way by simply applying for cosmetic surgery loans.

  12. He will sometimes guide you with extracting a unwanted food item like fatty, oily in addition to carbohydrates.

       Once you are on the calorie restricted diet and when the body
    demands energy, the HCG hormone will ensure that
    that energy is released from the stored fats and not from your lean muscle mass.

    HCG diet materials stress the importance of sticking to this diet.

  13. With the HCG Drops, the day of finally fitting into a pair of skinny jeans will not be a
    dream after all. And likewise, simply eating Muscle Builder Foods And doing Bodybuilding Workouts
    won’t add inches to your chest, arms, and shoulders, if you aren’t regularly pumping iron.
    Oz does not endorse the diet and believes that it is not effective for long term weight loss, but he does believe that some times the experience of real people has not caught up with science for documentation.

  14. But wе are only experiencing the time оf the present moment.
    (our last triangle player used one of my amps and ƅlew out a cone.
    Disco music is marκеd by many mսsicians from other genres jumping on the ɗisco bandwagon to
    produce hits.

  15. Several recent studies have shown Proscar is effective for hair
    loss and can help regrow some hair on some
    people, but as I said before, the use of 5AR inhibitors only deals with a
    part of the problem and are generally not very effective when used as the only treatment.
    Hair fall is a condition of losing hair from the scalp leading to the generation of new hair.
    * Ginkgo Biloba is an herb which has properties to help improve blood circulation to the scalp.

  16. Now when it comes to the actually tweezing part, you want to make sure that you’re using a good pair
    of tweezers. Pain medication is also provided in case the patient feels
    any discomfort the following few days. Alopecia areata is an inflammatory condition which can make hair come out in patches or clumps.

  17. Even frequent blow-drying at extreme heat or
    brushing obsessively can cause your hair to become extremely fragile causing it to break and fall out.
    Redheads and folks with course hair will typically be
    higher shedders than blondes or those with fine hair.
    We live in a climate that gets hot and humid and there are many
    activities to choose from.

  18. Usually I do not learn article oon blogs, but I would like to say thuat this write-up very pressured me to check out and do it!
    Your writing taste hhas been amazed me. Thanks, qquite great article.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: