Transportation Referendum is Acceptable, in the Short Term

by Joshua Marxen

When the issue of UCSD’s Transportation Services’ budget flared up at the end of last year, the California Review analyzed the issue and determined that the source of the problem was that the people riding the shuttles weren’t the ones paying for it. Instead, people driving to and from campus, paying for parking permits, and occasionally facing unreasonably strict ticketing practices, were the ones paying for the cost. With this kind of setup, people are incentivized to become consumers of the service, and not payers. Eventually, too many people are using the service, and not enough people are paying.

The recently passed transportation referendum is a step in the right direction. The language of the referendum states that “the [Student Transportation Fee]will provide UCSD students with a Regional Transit Pass for all undergraduate, graduate and professional students who pay this fee.” This way, the use of the service depends directly on the fact that the student using the service payed for it. This ensures that the program will have a stable financial base.

The referendum still falls short of ideal in several areas. First, there is still some unfairness left over from the previous scheme, due to the fact that students cannot opt out of the fee, so students who do not use MTS to get to school – most importantly, students who drive – must pay this fee on top of what they pay for expensive parking permits. While it is true that the cost of these permits has been rising because of the financial instability of the free shuttle program, and therefore the referendum should at least cut the rate of increase, we can not expect permit prices to start decreasing until TS has recouped its previous losses and replenished its reserves. This could take several years.

Furthermore, this is a one-size-fits-all solution, and is perhaps more expensive than most students need it to be. According to the referendum, “the Regional Transit Pass gives unlimited ridership… on all mass transit bus, trolley and light rail routes in the San Diego region provided by the San Diego Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and the North County Transit District (NCTD).” Most students only need access to the routes in the immediate vicinity of the UCSD campus – the same routes that free bus sticker would grant students access to. However, this does not seem to be a fault of the referendum. While MTS and NCTD were willing to drop their offer from $51 per quarter per pass to $39 (thus dropping the referendum amount from $65 to $50, due to the requirement that 29% of the fee go towards financial aid), they were unwilling to offer more than one transportation package to students with different needs.

One problem which is not really related to the referendum at all is that typically, shuttle drivers make an attempt to ration the number of seats they allocate to each shuttle stop, whereas MTS drivers do not make these considerations. If this situation does not change, then once UCSD shuttles are no longer running, people waiting in lines at later stops may lose the ability to take any bus or shuttle to school. (Protip: this is actually not true – cross the street and get on the bus going counterclockwise, which usually has no wait at all. The only downside is that this bus waits at the mall for several minutes, but typically students can jump from here to another bus going to campus, such as the 30, the 101, or the 150.)

To summarize, the referendum solves the problem of financial instability – TS will no longer have to pay anything for the transportation program, and the people using the service are the people paying for it. However, the solution is too broad, requiring students who don’t use it to pay for it, and charging students for more than they are likely to use. While this is probably the best solution we can get for the moment, we should remember these shortcomings and attempt to correct them in the future.



  1. Peter B · ·

    I find it disgusting honestly, it’s just making us pay far more than we need to and redistributing the financial aid of students again with a cut of it. I might need a bus pass later, might. But I’d rather see the free bus zone cancelled than MTS get a kickback of every student on campus paying for one. Especially when none of the money goes to the shuttles that everyone was throwing a little crybaby fit about.

    Sometimes, I really do think UCSD student’s really aren’t any brighter than the usual sheep. And the ASG just sneaks these referendums by with lies and unrelated threats.

  2. A person having little expertise meanwhile can handle these issues before a professional comes in frame.
    Arranging a remodeling dependably begins with great aims: “We should overhaul the split and peeling flooring, floor in the kitchen,” you say.
    Now we are going to evaluate kitchen remodeling projects.

  3. This product does not require sunbathing or messing with gooey unmanageable creams or complicated sprays.

    Relentless was now full of “old” players who weren’t interested in playing,
    but were interested in keeping the power. When you
    nourish the beauty within, you will also reflect that
    beauty outward to all you meet.

  4. When using such a solution, you will be asked to talk about the events that
    affected you in the year, marriage, new baby, move to a new house, started college,
    changed employment status, etc. They will do all the talking for you with
    the agent. Itemized deductions and personal exemptions do not affect self-employment taxes.

  5. Surgeons ask the patient to stop smoking cigarettes several weeks before the face lift surgery.
    For example, you might be seeking rhinoplasty as way to achieve a functional goal.
    This will give an assurance that the treatment which has offered
    is effective and suitable for you.

  6. Once you create your Expert Page, you can also begin networking
    with other Experts on. Meyers continues on to describe
    the correlation between this “shrinkage” and the presence
    of “sitelinks” within listings. It allows users to see all the daily changes in any security’s stock price without having to
    visit financial sites.

  7. Estimating the price of a kitchen improvement project will
    also involve negotiations using the skilled workers.
    A few indulgent upgrades to build cooking more interesting
    are welcome enhancements, too. An update sink fixture with great looking knobs can instantly update a plain and outdated kitchen counter and sink area.

  8. You can go to their websites and look for a listing for the doctors you are considering.
    Just like other facilities, medical facilities at
    Salt Lake City are quite advance and it has been serving different needs of
    the patients for the past many years. You also
    need to think about the recovery process and the ways it might
    affect your daily life and work.

  9. Hey there would you mind letting me know which hosting company you’re working with?
    I’ve loaded your blog in 3 different web browsers and I must say this blog
    loads a lot faster then most. Can you recommend
    a good hosting provider at a honest price? Many thanks, I appreciate it!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: